Members topic

Nuclear vs. the alternatives: what should power AI?

by Joe Miller

A data center needs a huge amount of power every minute of every day. Nuclear, natural gas, solar with batteries, wind, geothermal and the grid all compete for the job. Here's how they stack up on cost, reliability, speed and pollution, and what a nuclear engineer would pick.

What a data center needsWhich sources run 24/7What it costsSide by sideEach optionThe gas rushMy verdictSources

Plain-English explainer by Joe Miller, a nuclear engineer. Not investment advice. Figures are the latest public numbers we could find and change fast; sources are at the bottom of each page.

What a data center needs from its power

No single source wins on all four. That's why the answer is almost always a mix.

Which sources run around the clock?

How much of the time each source actually runs (capacity factor)Nuclearabout 93%Geothermalabout 70%Natural gas, combined cycleabout 60%Coalabout 45%Hydroabout 36%Windabout 34%Solarabout 24%Share of the year a plant runs at full output, U.S. fleet averages (EIA). A data center needs power 100% of the time.
Nuclear runs more of the year than anything else. Solar and wind need batteries or backup to run 24/7.

What new power costs

Cost of new power plants, dollars per megawatt-hour (Lazard 2026)$0$50$100$150$200$250$300Onshore wind$37 to $99only when the wind blowsUtility solar$40 to $98only when the sun shinesGas combined cycle$51 to $129runs on demand; fuel price riskGas peaker$144 to $276fast-start backupNew nuclear$175 to $255runs 24/7; slow to buildLazard Levelized Cost of Energy+ 2026, as reported by Utility Dive (July 2026). Wind and solar need batteries or backup to run around the clock, which adds cost.
Wind and solar are cheapest per megawatt-hour, but only when they're producing. New nuclear costs the most, but runs all the time.

Those numbers are for new plants. Power from existing nuclear plants, which were paid off long ago, is far cheaper; that's why tech companies are racing to sign deals with plants that are already running (see why Big Tech is buying nuclear). Lazard also found that battery storage costs went up in 2026 because of tariffs on imported batteries, and that new gas plants cost more because turbines are scarce.

Side by side

SourceRuns 24/7?Time to new powerCarbonThe catch
Existing nuclear (restart or buy)Yes, about 93% of the time0 to 4 yearsNoneOnly a few plants left to restart; buying from running plants takes power away from other customers
New nuclear (big or small reactors)YesAbout 2030 at the earliest; big plants about 10 yearsNoneMost expensive new power; first-of-a-kind projects run late
Natural gas, combined cycleYes, when fueled3 to 5 years; turbines sold out into 2029-2030About half of coalFuel prices swing; turbine shortage; pollution near the plant
Gas turbines on site ("behind the meter")YesMonths, if you can find turbinesHigher than combined cycleCostly to run; air permits and neighbors (see Colossus)
Solar plus batteriesOnly with enough batteries1 to 2 yearsNone while runningNeeds lots of land and 4+ hours of batteries; nights and cloudy weeks
WindNo, about 34% of the time2 to 4 yearsNone while runningWind comes and goes; transmission lines needed
GeothermalYes, about 70% or more3 to 5 yearsVery lowOnly a few hundred megawatts signed so far; best sites in the West
CoalYes, when runNo new plants being builtHighestOld plants kept open longer for data centers; most pollution
The grid (a mix of everything)YesSeveral years in many regionsDepends on regionWaiting lines to connect; costs can spread to homeowners

Times and ranges are typical U.S. figures and vary a lot by project.

Each option, in plain English

Nuclear

The best fit on paper: it runs about 93% of the time, makes no carbon, and a 1,000-megawatt plant fits on about a square mile. The problem is time and cost. Restarting a closed plant takes two to four years, and only a handful are left. New reactors, including small modular reactors, are aimed at about 2030 at the earliest and cost the most of any new power. Big Tech has still signed close to 10 gigawatts of nuclear deals, because nothing else gives carbon-free power around the clock.

Natural gas

Today's workhorse. Gas is the largest source of U.S. electricity, it can run on demand, and new combined-cycle plants are relatively cheap. About 30% of planned data center capacity is set to use power built on site, mostly gas, according to a Cleanview analysis reported by E&E News. The catch: turbines are sold out. GE Vernova, Siemens Energy and Mitsubishi have a combined backlog of about 220 gigawatts, with delivery slots stretching into 2029 and 2030, and Wood Mackenzie expects turbine prices to be nearly triple their 2019 level by the end of 2027. Gas also burns fuel whose price swings, and it emits carbon and smog-forming pollution.

Solar plus batteries

The cheapest new energy and the fastest to build. Solar went to almost 9% of U.S. electricity in 2025. The catch: it only produces about a quarter of the time. To run a data center all night, you need a large battery bank, and to ride through a cloudy week you still need something else. Land is the other limit: about 5 to 10 acres per megawatt of panels.

Wind

Cheap when it blows, often strongest at night, which pairs well with solar. The catch: it runs about a third of the time, and the best wind is often far from where data centers are being built.

Geothermal

The dark horse. Heat from deep underground runs around the clock with almost no emissions. New drilling methods borrowed from the oil and gas industry are opening up more sites. Google has signed with Fervo and Ormat, and Meta with Sage Geosystems and XGS Energy, each deal in the 115 to 150 megawatt range. The catch: it's still small, and the best sites are in the West.

Coal and the grid

No one is building new coal plants, but some utilities are keeping old ones open longer to meet data center demand. Most data centers still plug into the grid, which is a mix of everything above. The problem is the line to connect: several years in many regions, and the cost of new grid capacity can land on everyone's bill (see your electric bill).

Why gas is winning right now

If you need a gigawatt in two years, gas is usually the only thing you can get, if you can find turbines. Developers are using truck-mounted generators and turbines taken from aircraft and ships to get power faster. Elon Musk's Colossus in Memphis ran dozens of gas turbines on site and ended up in court over air permits (see Elon Musk, Colossus and data centers in space). Expect most new data center power in the 2020s to be gas, with nuclear, geothermal and solar plus batteries growing behind it.

My verdict as a nuclear engineer

Short term, through about 2030: gas and the grid do the heavy lifting, with solar and batteries cutting fuel use during the day. Nuclear restarts like Crane (2027) and Duane Arnold (2029) add a few gigawatts of clean, steady power.

Long term, the 2030s: if small reactors come in close to their targets, nuclear is the best match for what a data center needs: steady, compact, carbon-free and immune to fuel price swings for decades. Geothermal is the one to watch as a second clean, round-the-clock option. Solar and wind will keep growing because they're cheap, but they need storage or backup to run a data center.

What it means for you: the mix your local data center picks decides your air quality, your water and, through the grid, part of your electric bill. Ask your utility commission and local officials which power a new data center will use, and who pays for it.

Members: $15 a month

Half the topics are free. Members get the other half, plus the monthly Data Center Critical newsletter with the month's AI, chip and power news. Cancel anytime.

Join for $15/month

Who's writing this? I'm Joe Miller, a nuclear engineer. I spent my career around power plants, so when the AI boom turned into a race for electricity, I started digging. This site explains what I've found in plain English. My story is at criticalmassbook.com.

Sources

Checked November 16, 2026.